It's been almost a year now since my last post. My WordPress install broke badly and I didn't have the courage to take on that much PHP. I tried a bunch of minimalist blogging engines out and rolled a few of my own, before I got to this one.
This is a very small amount of Rails with a very simple HTML template and some light background magic.
Comments
The bit I enjoyed most about posting to my old blog were the comments people would leave. I like seeing a discussion form, even if it's only to show how completely wrong I am about something. One of the designs I tried out had a similar 2 column layout with the comments displayed side by side with my post on the front page. As much attention on the discussion as the post.
I didn't like how comments worked though. I really don't want to own your thoughts on my posts, so I didn't see any reason to build and maintain another comment silo. That ruled out Disqus for me too.
Instead, I'm going to try out Twitter for comments. What makes it different from Disqus for me is how widely it's used and how easily it's mashed up to create strange, odd little apps.
First, I was going to use #hashtags to find comments on my posts.
Something like:
"I preferred your old blog #first-post"
but that keeps other people out of the conversation. What are your followers supposed to do when they see that tag? Be confused probably.
Instead, I've gone with a link back to my post using a shortcode, to identify comments on a post. So replies look like:
"I preferred the hashtags tbh http://dogg.ie/.knqtmh"
Things I like about this approach
- All comments stay in the commenters' public timeline feed, you own your own comment.
- A comment is linked to a commenters' twitter account, I get a free identity service. Makes blocking a spammer easier, among other things.
- You can check out what else a commenter has to say, maybe start following them too.
Things I dislike
- You need a Twitter account to participate. I expect most of the people who read my blog already have one, but it's still a barrier.
- It feels a little bit too self-promoting. I'm expecting other people to put a link to my site in their public twitter timeline. I hope that's considered less as spam, more a way to keep the conversation coherent.
- Comment length is limited. Even with shortcoded URLs, there's still a very small space for a message. I'd hope that if I've said something you really want to respond to, you'll post in your own blog and tweet a reply that links to both.
The old stuff
I've got an archive of all my old posts and comments. I've chosen not to post them yet, maybe I'll review them and repost them, maybe I'll create an archive somewhere — I'm not sure yet.
I'm a bit embarrassed by them you see, some of the stuff I posted (like short tips) came about after I noticed they got the most traffic from Google, so I started to write more short tips just for the hits. I think that was a mistake.
At the same time, they were obviously useful to some people, maybe I'll create a whole other section of tips with a separate feed. I'm open to suggestions.
Thanks
So that's the new blog introduced. Hope it stirs you up enough to get a reply. Thanks for staying subscribed.
29 comments